Au pair or childminder
What is the best choice for your family?
What is a Childminder?
A childminder is a certified childcare provider who cares for children in a home environment. This can be in her own home or in the parents’ home. Childminders are often more flexible than daycare centers and can offer a more personal approach. Childminders must meet strict legal requirements, such as registration in the National Childcare Register and Playgroups (LRKP), having a relevant diploma (e.g., pedagogy), and a valid Certificate of Conduct (VOG).
What does a Childminder do exactly?
A childminder provides care and supervision for children, usually in a smaller and more intimate setting than a daycare center. The tasks of a childminder may include:
- Preparing meals and snacks.
- Organizing educational and recreational activities.
- Supporting young children in their development, such as language and motor skills.
- Taking and picking up children from school or other activities
How does childminder care work?
Childminders usually operate through an agency. This agency facilitates registration, mediation, and administration between childminders and parents. Parents pay the nanny through the agency, and the agency ensures that the care meets legal requirements.
Parents may be eligible for childcare allowance if the childminder is registered with the LRKP. The hourly rate for a childminder typically ranges between €5 and €7 per child, depending on the location and experience of the childminder.
| Au pair | Gastouder | |
|---|---|---|
| Costs | Pocket money (€340 per month) + room and board; additional costs for insurance, travel expenses, and mediation fees. | €5-€7 per hour per child; total cost may be higher for multiple children. |
| Tasks and responsibilities | Childcare and light household chores such as cooking and cleaning. | Focus on childcare; household chores are usually not included. |
| Flexibility | Flexible schedule: maximum eight hours per day/thirty hours per week/minimum two days off. | More flexible than daycare centers, but bound to specific care times. |
| Cultural enrichment | Introduces new customs, languages, and traditions into the family. | Provides a safe environment, but usually does not contribute to cultural enrichment. |
| Childcare allowance | Not applicable. | Available if the childminder is registered with the LRKP. |
Comparison: au pair vs childminder
Costs
Au pair: an au pair receives pocket money (€340 per month in the Netherlands) and room and board. Additional costs may include insurance, travel expenses, and mediation fees.
Childminder: the costs for a childminder range between €5-€7 per hour per child. Depending on the number of children, this can add up to a higher monthly amount than an au pair.
Tasks and responsibilities
Au pair: in addition to childcare, an au pair also helps with light household chores, such as cooking and cleaning.
Childminder: the focus is mainly on childcare. Light household work is usually not part of the childminder’s tasks.
Flexibility
Au pair: within legal frameworks (maximum eight hours per day, maximum thirty hours per week, and at least two full days off), you can set up a weekly schedule. An au pair can also be used in the evenings.
Childminder: although childminders are often more flexible than daycare centers, they have specific care times and cannot always work outside these times.
Cultural enrichment
Au pair: the biggest advantage of an au pair is cultural exchange. The au pair introduces new customs, languages, and traditions into the family.
Childminder: a childminder provides a safe and familiar environment but usually does not contribute to cultural enrichment.
Childcare allowance
Au pair: au pairs are not eligible for childcare allowance.
Childminder: parents can apply for childcare allowance if the childminder is registered with the LRKP.
Comparison: au pair vs childminder
Costs
Au pair: an au pair receives pocket money (€340 per month in the Netherlands) and room and board. Additional costs may include insurance, travel expenses, and mediation fees.
Childminder: the costs for a childminder range between €5-€7 per hour per child. Depending on the number of children, this can add up to a higher monthly amount than an au pair.
Tasks and responsibilities
Au pair: in addition to childcare, an au pair also helps with light household chores, such as cooking and cleaning.
Childminder: the focus is mainly on childcare. Light household work is usually not part of the childminder’s tasks.
Flexibility
Au pair: within legal frameworks (maximum eight hours per day, maximum thirty hours per week, and at least two full days off), you can set up a weekly schedule. An au pair can also be used in the evenings.
Childminder: although childminders are often more flexible than daycare centers, they have specific care times and cannot always work outside these times.
Cultural enrichment
Au pair: the biggest advantage of an au pair is cultural exchange. The au pair introduces new customs, languages, and traditions into the family.
Childminder: a childminder provides a safe and familiar environment but usually does not contribute to cultural enrichment.
Childcare allowance
Au pair: au pairs are not eligible for childcare allowance.
Childminder: parents can apply for childcare allowance if the childminder is registered with the LRKP.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
An au pair lives with the family, provides childcare and light household work, and brings cultural enrichment. A childminder works independently, often from her own home, and focuses solely on childcare.
For families with multiple children, au pairs are often cheaper because their fee is fixed. With childminders, you pay per child, which can quickly add up.
An au pair is generally more flexible because she lives in the house and can adapt to irregular schedules. Childminders have fixed working hours that are agreed upon in advance.
No, childcare allowance is only available for care registered with the LRKP, such as childminder care.
Yes, childminders can provide night care, but this must be agreed upon in advance and may incur additional costs.
If an au pair does not fit well with the family, the au pair agency can help find a solution, such as re-placement or additional guidance.
Yes, many childminders offer homework support, especially for young children. This should be discussed in advance.
An au pair can stay in the Netherlands for a maximum of 12 months.
Yes, many childminders charge extra for care outside regular working hours. It is important to clarify this in advance.
It depends on your family situation. If you value cultural enrichment, flexibility, and help in the house, an au pair is a better choice. If you prefer to use childcare allowance and seek a professional care environment, a childminder is more suitable.
Au pair, childcare, childminder or nanny
What is the best choice for your family?
View the comparisons here:
Are you aiming for a successful experience?
Au Pair International has been guiding host families for over 15 years. In a non-binding introduction call, we will inform you on how to make your period as a host family a success!